This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomePhenomenon of Interest
|
5 pts
Met
Confers and confirms topic with faculty. Clearly states topic and relevance to Nursing. States problem in PICO format and shares topic in PICO format with class.
|
2.5 pts
Partially met
Areas of improvement needed. Edit recommendations not fully incorporated.
|
0 pts
Not Met/ No submission
Not Met/ No submission
|
|
5 pts
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeSignificance of Problem / Background
|
15 pts
Met
Establishes significance of problem. Uses primary sources to support statements about significance of problem. Identifies current standards of practice.
|
7.5 pts
Partially met
Areas of improvement needed. Edit recommendations not fully incorporated.
|
0 pts
Not Met/ No submission
Not Met/ No submission
|
|
15 pts
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeStatement of Purpose
|
5 pts
Met
Clearly states the purpose of the literature review. Describes briefly search techniques employed to locate studies reviewed. Inclusion and exclusion criteria for studies used in review. Locates 10 pertinent studies for use in Literature Review.
|
2.5 pts
Partially met
Areas of improvement needed. Edit recommendations not fully incorporated.
|
0 pts
Not Met/ No submission
Not Met/ No submission
|
|
5 pts
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeLiterature Review Table
|
10 pts
Met
Table includes each research study reviewed in the critique of the literature. Table columns address significant aspects of the studies / phenomenon of interest. Provides detailed information not provided in text of paper. Is inserted at the end of the paper as Appendix 1.
|
5 pts
Partially met
Areas of improvement needed. Edit recommendations not fully incorporated.
|
0 pts
Not Met/ No submission
Not Met/ No submission
|
|
10 pts
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeCritique of the Literature
|
25 pts
Met
Content is organized, identifying key aspects of the phenomenon using subject headings as appropriate. Synthesizes critique of reviewed studies on issues of research design, framework, sampling methods, analysis and reporting of results, etc.
|
12.5 pts
Partially met
Areas of improvement needed. Edit recommendations not fully incorporated.
|
0 pts
Not Met/ No submission
Not Met/ No submission
|
|
25 pts
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeConclusion
|
20 pts
Met
Summarizes the findings from the literature. Identifies implications for Nursing Practice. Makes recommendations for future practice.
|
10 pts
Partially met
Areas of improvement needed. Edit recommendations not fully incorporated.
|
0 pts
Not Met/ No submission
Not Met/ No submission
|
|
20 pts
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeStyle
|
10 pts
Met
Adheres to APA 7th Edition format (Margins, headings, font, size and reference style). Logical flow and clear presentation of information. Uses proper / professional grammar, syntax and punctuation. Minimum 10 pages, maximum 13 (excluding title page, tables, and references).
|
5 pts
Partially met
Areas of improvement needed. Edit recommendations not fully incorporated.
|
0 pts
Not Met/ No submission
Not Met/ No submission
|
|
10 pts
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeReferences
|
10 pts
Met
Reference list includes a minimum of 10 studies reviewed (>12 may be used for background information). Refs are current (within the last 5 yrs.) unless explained. In-text citations match references listed.
|
5 pts
Partially met
Areas of improvement needed. Edit recommendations not fully incorporated.
|
0 pts
Not Met/ No submission
Not Met/ No submission
|
|
10
|