This week’s reading (Writing Commons: CritiqueLinks to an external site.) identifies a number of different kinds of critique, feedback, and peer review. These include:
- Formative Feedback
- Summative Feedback
- Global Critique
- Local Critique
- The Side Note
- Rubric-based feedback
- Endnotes
- Line-by-Line Editing
Familiarize yourself with these different forms of critique and respond to the following questions:
- Which of these critique forms do you find most valuable to receive, either from peers or your professors? Why?
- Which of these forms are easiest and which are most challenging for you to provide to others? Explain your answer.
Finally, the reading makes this point: “Feedback is deeply rhetorical.”
- What does this mean?
- What is the risk of feedback that is not rhetorical?